6 Easy Ways to Refresh an Outdated Fireplace Without Knocking It Down, According to Contractors

Updating a fireplace can seem challenging. While it’s easy to repaint the walls, swap light fixtures, and even replace flooring to give your space a whole new look, updating a fireplace is a more hands-on job. However, upgrading an outdated fireplace can truly transform your space.

Below, we’ve explained how to upgrade an outdated fireplace without a full demo, and offered pro tips from renovation experts for overhauling your fireplace’s look.

Paint or Refinish the Surround

As with many other home renovations, nothing matches the power of paint, and the same goes for your fireplace surround.

If removing and replacing the materials surrounding the fireplace isn’t an option, Kevin Vander Hyde, Vice President of Vander Hyde Services, recommends a coat of heat-resistant paint to completely change the fireplace’s look.

There’s really no limit to what you can do with paint. While you could easily cover the brick, stone, or other materials in a solid coat of paint, don’t be afraid to experiment with patterns and multiple colors. You can even paint each tile to give the appearance of a whole new patterned tile.

Want more home reno project tips and inspiration? Sign up for our free daily newsletter for the latest how-tos, reno guides, and more!

Add a Mantel or Update an Existing One

Sometimes, changing just one element of a fireplace is enough to completely transform its overall appearance.

“Installing a sleek wood, stone, or reclaimed mantel can modernize the space and give it a focal point,” Vander Hyde says.

Building a DIY mantel is a great starter DIY project for any level of do-it-yourselfer, as there are several DIY mantel ideas to fit various skill levels.

Apply a Tile or Stone Veneer

“Thin stone or tile veneers can be applied over existing surfaces to create a high-end look without demolition,” Vander Hyde says.

If the surface is smooth and clean, Danny Niemela, Licensed Contractor and Vice President and CFO at ArDan Construction, says that peel-and-stick stone or ceramic tiles will often adhere directly to it.

“If you are working with uneven brick or other surfaces with jagged edges, you can skim coat the face with cement board or mortar to create a flat canvas,” he suggests. “This will take you around two hours and maybe $100 in materials. Add the tile, grout, and a new mantel, and you have an entirely different look by the end of the weekend.”

Install a Fireplace Insert

For fireplaces that aren’t operational, Vander Hyde recommends homeowners consider electric or gas inserts that can provide heat and a realistic flame without any demolition or major construction.

Update Hardware and Accessories

The easiest way to update your fireplace without any demolition is to replace the hardware and accessories. Vander Hyde recommends new screens, new grates, and fireplace tools to refresh the current look without painting or replacing any materials.

Add Built-ins or Shelves Around the Fireplace

Instead of thinking about how to update your fireplace without demolition, consider changing the visual context of your space to elevate its current look. Adding wallpaper, painting the surrounding walls, or building shelves and cabinets can change the space entirely.

“Framing the fireplace with built-ins or shelving can modernize the room and draw attention away from outdated features,” Vander Hyde says.

How to Update an Outdated Fireplace That Doesn’t Work

Many fireplaces no longer function, due to material degradation or years of neglected maintenance, but you can still refresh their looks.

These fireplace update ideas will impart a sense of warmth and ambiance to your space, even if they can’t generate actual heat.

• Add decorative logs. Both Vander Hyde and Niemela agree that adding decorative logs to the firebox is a quick, easy, and effective way to revamp an outdated, nonoperational fireplace.
• Install LED inserts. Both experts advocate using LED inserts in a non-operational fireplace, with Niemela specifically suggesting LED uplighting within the firebox or beneath the mantel.
• Place candles in the fireplace. Even something as simple as placing candles inside the firebox or on the hearth can dress up an outdated fireplace that no longer works.

Tips for Updating a Fireplace Without a Full Demo

Ready to tackle the fireplace makeover you’ve been dreaming about? Follow these tips for updating a fireplace without a full demo.

• Use paint where possible. Painting can make a big difference with a very small impact on your budget and without any demolition. Just be sure to use heat-resistant paint if the fireplace is operational.
• Swap easy-to-change details. Rather than attempting to demo and rebuild your outdated fireplace, consider updating the elements that are easiest to change, such as the mantel.
• Add new accessories. It’s always easier to add accessories to a fireplace than change the fireplace itself. Updating hardware, tools, screens, and more can give your fireplace a whole new look with construction.
• Add a fireplace insert. If you’re looking to make a non-operational wood-burning fireplace functional again, consider installing an electric or gas insert; just be sure to check local safety codes before installing.
• Add built-ins and shelves. Simply updating the space surrounding your fireplace can offer new visual context and elevate the entire look without even touching the fireplace itself. Oftentimes, you’ll find you loved the existing fireplace more than you thought.